5 Best Reels for St. Croix Custom Ice Rods: Top Picks for Ice Fishing Success

You might wonder if pairing your St. Croix Custom Ice Rod with any reel will get the job done.

The truth is, not all reels perform equally well in icy conditions or offer the smooth control you need for success.

Choosing the right reel can make a significant difference in your ice fishing experience.

Let’s explore some top options that complement these rods perfectly and why they stand out.

St. Croix Skandic Ice Rod

No products found.

The St. Croix Skandic Ice Rod is designed for ice fishing enthusiasts targeting walleye, trout, or perch. Its 24-inch length and SC Precision-taper solid carbon blanks provide excellent sensitivity and durability. The rod’s medium-light power and fast action make it well-suited for freshwater ice spinning and casting.

This ice fishing rod features SeaGuide light wire guides that help reduce ice buildup, enhancing performance in cold conditions. The premium cork handle ensures a comfortable grip. Color-coded tips make it easier to detect strikes quickly, adding to its practical design.

Best for: anglers seeking a sensitive, durable ice fishing rod for freshwater species like walleye, trout, and perch.

Pros:

  • SC Precision-taper solid carbon blanks offer great sensitivity and strength
  • SeaGuide light wire guides minimize ice buildup
  • Comfortable premium cork handle for better grip

Cons:

  • Length may not suit all ice fishing styles
  • Medium-light power might not handle larger fish as well
  • Some users report varied experience with performance

Ice Fishing Rod and Reel Combo, 27″ Medium Light Spinning Ice Fishing Pole

No products found.

The 27″ Medium Light Spinning Ice Fishing Rod and Reel Combo is designed for anglers who value sensitivity and strength. Made from solid fiberglass, this combo delivers precise feel and durability. It targets species like trout, walleye, and bass effectively in cold conditions.

The rod features a hollow reel seat with silver and black accents and an EVA handle for a comfortable, secure grip. Stainless steel guide rings help prevent line freezing, enhancing reliability on the ice. The lightweight aluminum alloy reel includes a smooth 3+1 ball bearing system for effortless operation.

This ice fishing pole and reel combo balances performance and comfort, making it a practical choice for serious anglers. Its design focuses on functionality, ensuring smooth and enjoyable fishing experiences.

Best for: Ice anglers seeking a sensitive and durable rod and reel combo for cold-weather fishing targeting trout, walleye, and bass.

Pros:

  • Solid fiberglass construction for excellent sensitivity and strength
  • Stainless steel guide rings reduce line freezing
  • Lightweight aluminum reel with smooth 3+1 ball bearings for reliable performance

Cons:

  • Medium light power may be less ideal for larger fish
  • Rod length might be short for those preferring longer poles
  • Limited color options with a silver and black design

Okuma Cold Water Linecounter Trolling Reel

No products found.

The Okuma Cold Water Linecounter Trolling Reel features a lightweight, corrosion-resistant composite frame, ideal for harsh, cold environments. Its multi-disc Carbonite drag system paired with a ratcheting drag star offers precise drag control for smooth, reliable performance.

Equipped with XL gearing and a self-lubricating drop-down gearbox, this reel ensures smooth operation whether you’re trolling or jigging through ice. Weighing just 413 grams, it is designed for easy handling with your right hand.

See Also-  5 Best Ice Fishing Rod and Reel Combos for Crappie in 2025 – Expert Picks

Best for: anglers who need a durable, lightweight trolling reel built specifically for cold water and ice fishing conditions.

Pros:

  • Corrosion-resistant frame for harsh conditions
  • Precise multi-disc Carbonite drag system
  • Smooth XL gearing with self-lubricating gearbox
  • Lightweight and easy to handle

Cons:

  • Primarily designed for right-hand use
  • Compatible only with monofilament lines
  • Package weight might affect portability for some users

Piscifun ICX II Ice Fishing Reel, Size 500, Ultra Smooth 5+1 Ball Bearings, Lightweight 5.9oz

No products found.

The Piscifun ICX II Ice Fishing Reel, Size 500, offers a lightweight yet durable design ideal for cold environments. Its high-strength graphite body and CNC aluminum spool resist water and freezing damage, ensuring reliable performance. The reel features 5+1 sealed ball bearings and a zinc alloy drive gear for an ultra-smooth 5.2:1 retrieval ratio.

This ice fishing reel includes an instant anti-reverse mechanism and a foldable handle for easy transport. The extended stem allows comfortable use while wearing gloves, making it practical for harsh winter conditions. Its bold design adds a modern touch to your fishing gear.

Best for: anglers seeking a smooth, durable ice fishing reel that works well in cold weather and can be handled easily with gloves.

Pros:

  • Smooth retrieval with 5+1 sealed ball bearings and zinc alloy gear
  • Durable graphite body and CNC aluminum spool resistant to cold and water
  • Instant anti-reverse and foldable handle for convenience
  • Extended stem designed for gloved operation

Cons:

  • May be limited to ice fishing use only
  • Might not suit anglers targeting very large fish
  • Could offer more color options for customization

13 FISHING Descent Inline Ice Fishing Reel (Gen 2) – Right Hand Retrieve, Black

No products found.

The 13 Fishing Descent Inline Ice Fishing Reel (Gen 2) is designed for anglers needing a lightweight and durable reel in cold environments. Constructed from rigid graphite composite, it weighs just 7.5 ounces and performs well with mono, fluoro, and braided lines. Its 2.7:1 gear ratio ensures smooth retrieves, supported by five stainless steel ball bearings and an instant anti-reverse for precise control.

This reel features a disc drag system that provides up to 4.4 pounds of drag, allowing for accurate line tension management. The push-button spool and drop speed control enhance the ice fishing experience by enabling easy adjustments. Its right-hand retrieve design suits many users looking for reliable performance on the ice.

Best for: anglers seeking a compact, reliable ice fishing reel with smooth operation and versatile line compatibility.

Pros:

  • Lightweight at 7.5 ounces with strong graphite composite build
  • Smooth 2.7:1 gear ratio and five stainless steel ball bearings
  • Instant anti-reverse and disc drag up to 4.4 pounds
  • Push-button spool and drop speed control for fine tuning

Cons:

  • Right-hand retrieve only, which might limit left-handed users
  • Drag capacity may be lower for very large or strong fish
  • Moderate popularity compared to some other ice fishing reels
See Also-  The 5 Best Selling Ice Fishing Reels of 2025 - Top Picks for Every Angler

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Reel for St Croix Custom Ice Rod

When picking a reel for your St Croix Custom Ice Rod, make sure the size matches the rod’s specifications for smooth performance. You’ll want a strong drag system and high-quality bearings to handle tough fish and cold conditions.

Also, consider the reel’s weight and durability to keep your setup balanced and reliable on the ice.

Reel Size Compatibility

Choosing the right reel size for your St. Croix Custom Ice Rod is essential for ideal balance and performance. You want a reel that matches the rod’s specifications, typically between size 1000 and 2500 for medium-light rods. These sizes offer enough line capacity and weight to handle popular species like walleye and trout effectively.

Keep the reel’s weight in check; it shouldn’t exceed the rod’s balance point, so you maintain sensitivity and ease of use. Also, verify the reel can hold line within the 4-8 pound range recommended for your rod. Don’t forget to take into account the gear ratio—it should complement the rod’s action, with faster ratios preferred for quick retrieval during active ice fishing.

This compatibility guarantees a smooth, efficient fishing experience.

Drag System Strength

Because controlling line tension is essential during ice fishing, you’ll want a reel with a strong, reliable drag system for your St. Croix Custom Ice Rod. A powerful drag lets you manage resistance smoothly, preventing line breakage when fighting species like walleye or trout that can make sudden runs. Check the maximum drag strength—measured in pounds—and confirm it matches your target fish’s size and your line weight.

The drag should engage and release without abrupt stops to avoid damaging your line during key moments. Also, consider the drag system’s materials and construction since durability and consistent performance in freezing conditions are critical. Choosing a reel with these drag features guarantees you stay in control, improving your chances of landing the catch under tough ice fishing conditions.

Bearing Quality and Count

A strong drag system keeps your line secure, but the reel’s bearing quality and count determine how smoothly you bring in your catch. When ice fishing, you’ll want a reel with at least 5+1 stainless steel bearings for smooth operation and reduced friction in cold conditions. High-quality bearings guarantee efficient retrieval, making it easier to feel subtle bites and control your catch.

Sealed bearings add extra protection against water and ice penetration, preserving performance and durability. Keep in mind that bearing quality works hand in hand with gear ratio to affect reel speed and power, so choose a reel that balances these factors well. Prioritizing bearing quality and count will enhance your overall ice fishing experience with your St. Croix custom rod.

Weight and Balance

Reel weight plays an important role in matching the medium-light power of your St. Croix Custom Ice Rod. You’ll want a lighter reel, typically between 5 to 8 ounces, to maintain balance and prevent fatigue during long ice fishing sessions. A well-balanced setup improves sensitivity, helping you detect subtle bites more easily—a significant advantage when finesse matters.

See Also-  The 5 Best Ice Fishing Rod and Reel Cases for 2025 – Protect Your Gear in Style

Since your rod is around 24 inches, an overly heavy reel can throw off its natural action and performance. Verify the reel’s weight distributes evenly to reduce strain on your wrist and arm. By focusing on weight and balance, you guarantee a more comfortable, responsive fishing experience that keeps you angling longer without discomfort or lost opportunities.

Durability in Cold

When you fish in freezing temperatures, choosing gear that withstands the cold is crucial to avoid performance issues. You want a reel built with corrosion-resistant, lightweight materials that won’t crack or warp in low temperatures. Sealed ball bearings are a must—they keep ice and moisture out, guaranteeing your reel operates smoothly.

Look for a multi-disc carbonite drag system to maintain reliable adjustments, even when battling fish in icy conditions. High-strength bodies and rotors engineered for winter elements add extra durability. Also, consider the handle design; it should be easy to grip and turn while wearing gloves.

Line Capacity Needs

How much line capacity do you really need for your St. Croix Custom Ice Rod? It depends on your target species and fishing style. Since your rod supports line weights between 4-8 pounds, pick a reel that handles this range smoothly.

If you’re fishing in deeper waters or targeting strong, fast fish like walleye, opt for reels with larger capacity to avoid running out of line. Heavier baits and strong currents also demand more line to prevent breakage. Don’t forget to factor in the type of line you use—some lines are thicker or stretch more, requiring additional capacity.

Matching your reel’s capacity to these conditions guarantees you won’t be caught off guard and can fish confidently every time.

Conclusion

So, you want to conquer the ice with your St. Croix Custom Ice Rod, huh? Well, grabbing one of these reels—whether it’s the Okuma’s precision, Piscifun’s smooth glide, or the futuristic 13 Fishing Descent—means you’re already halfway to fishing glory.

Because nothing says “ice fishing pro” like a reel that won’t freeze up or throw a tantrum when you hook the big one. Choose wisely, or prepare to talk to your line more than the fish!